![]() |
In the Garden, William Forsyth in the IMA Collection at Newfields was exhibited at the 1893 Chicago World's Fair |
How They Spent Last Summer.
The first national triumph for artist William Forsyth occurred in 1893, when three of his paintings were chosen for display in the World's Columbian Exhibition, also known as the Chicago World's Fair that year.
The scenic location of the origin of the artworks he created for that exhibition would prove important, in what can be viewed as a pivot southward by some pioneering Indianapolis-based artists in search of picturesque subjects for their pictures.
Modern American impressionistic artworks would be created in several southern Indiana locations in the following years, such as near the Whitewater River at Brookville, Brown County near Nashville and the Ohio River at various locations such as Hanover, Madison and Corydon.
A large body of work by many of the foundational Indiana artists would serve to develop an overall Hoosier style. A style that would define the first age of excellence in Indiana art history; the Society of Western Artists period, and the eventual Hoosier Group and Brown County styles.
But first there was the ancient Indiana town of Old Vernon, that first caught the attention of one such artist, and then second a few years later. Nestled in a horseshoe bend of the Muscatatuck River in what is now Jennings County, Indiana, a beautiful hamlet that was founded by U. S. surveyor Col. John Vawter in 1815, and some 80 years later in the post Civil War period was a time capsule of quaint and sturdy brick buildings in the Federal style, and townfolk seemingly just as quaint and sturdy. All insulated from time and progress by the town's remote location and a river that surrounded on three sides.
![]() |
On the Muscatatuck by T. C. Steele, drawing by the artist based on painting that was exhibited in 1893 Chicago World's Fair |
An Indianapolis Journal article on November 13, 1892, describes the recent summer's activities of artists T. C. Steele and William Forsyth in creating pictures for a show at the Lieber art gallery, in Indianapolis that fall.
The article thoroughly covers the genesis of the joint exhibition that would feature works by both men that captured their crucial change of scenery southward, in search of a new and beautiful terrain, and is quoted in length as follows,
“...T.C. Steele and William Forsyth have gathered the fruits of their summer outing on the Muscatatuck, in the vicinity of Old Vernon, Jennings county, and will begin an exhibit of their work at Lieber's beginning to-morrow.
Seven years ago, soon after his return from Europe, Mr. Steele was told of the material that nature had spread on the banks of the winding river, and the following summer found him in Old Vernon. He was delighted with the place and went to work with enthusiasm. That summer's work added greatly to his reputation.
...He did not return to Old Vernon until summer before last (1891), when he was accompanied by Mr. Forsyth. (This) Last summer they again went there, and from June till October have been busily at work. As a result of this last visit each shows eighteen or twenty completed pictures.”
The article goes on the explain the magical attraction of the town and vicinity for artists,
“The picturesqueness of this neighborhood of Old Vernon is not confined to inanimate nature. The people themselves are quaint, old-fashioned folk, quite as good subjects for canvas as can be found in Holland or Brittany. The stream of commerce rushes by leaving them in a quiet little pool at its edge...
Age has ripened the town for the painter's use. Some of the houses there were built as early as 1816, the year in which Indiana was made a State...”
The immediate reaction of a local morning newspaper art critic to William Forsyth's paintings in the Lieber show in 1892 is referred to about a year later in an article in The Indianapolis News, March 13, 1893.
![]() |
The Blue Pool, aka Landscape, aka Morning on the Muscatatuck by William Forsyth, drawing by the artist based on painting that was exhibited in 1893 Chicago World's Fair |
Over several columns in the paper, the writer reveals that Forsyth has been selected as an artist, with three paintings, in the prestigious, upcoming Chicago World's Fair.
With success, comes criticism, and the knives come out upon news of Forsyth's achievement. Criticisms accrued regarding his use of the new impressionist style – his color and technique of immediacy, of painting rapidly in the open air.
A first article, in the hindsight of today, presents the views of a rather stodgy art critic, unnamed, who is quoted by the writer of The News article of March 1893, also unnamed, as follows,
“Mr. Forsyth uses impressionistic business so freely that, while he strikes it right once in awhile, many of his pictures are not effective. Here (in the Lieber exhibit of 1892) are about sixteen pictures...all produced in the past three months, many of them large canvases. (He has) not had time to study out the coloring and compose skies – and most of the pictures show it.
It is difficult to see why 'impressionism' is popular with the public, further than the public usually takes the artists' word for it, but it is easy to see why it is popular with artists. Most buyers, who are not connoisseurs, really measure the value of a painting by its size, and any artist can dash off an 'impression' of the $300 size in less time than it takes to tell about it; and it he doesn't know how to draw, nobody is ever going to discover that fact, while, if his coloring is bad, nobody but artists will know it, and they won't tell.”
![]() |
September by T. C. Steele, drawing by the artist based on painting that was exhibited in 1893 Chicago World's Fair |
About a month later, art critic C. A Plimpton writing for the Cincinnati Commercial Gazette and reprinted in The Indianapolis Journal on April 19, 1893, covered the 10th Annual Art Association of Indianapolis exhibit. His review also calls out Forsyth and T. C. Steele for criticism, ridiculing their (and other artists) contemporary painting style,
“The Art Association of (Indianapolis) is holding its tenth annual exhibition...
There are something less than two hundred pictures being exhibited, mostly from Eastern dealers, and, in the main, very good. The most interesting feature of the affair is the struggle among the patrons and critics to know what is good and what shall be purchased by the association at the end of the exhibit...
Most are certain of one thing – that no picture in the collection can be better than those those of their two (almost only) artists, T. C. Steele and William Forsyth, because, forsooth, they had 'triumphs at Chicago!'
When anything of the 'impressionist' style is so broad in handling or violent in color that it cannot be made out withing ten feet of it, the observer goes back the length of the hall and summons, as he says, sufficient 'studied innocence' (that is good) to comprehend the thing. Now, this may be all very fine for people who can support a fifty-foot long gallery in which to cast observations, but for the ordinary salon parlor it is bad.”
The critic's mocking tone is indicative of a preference towards the naturalistic painting style that preceded the impressionist era. Indeed, he compares a portrait painting by artist C. T. Webber as a “beautiful contrast” to a portrait work by William (Merritt) Chase in the show, of “a pale young man with so much red in his ear and on his knuckles that it looks like blood that will not 'out.'
Over a century later, modern eyes would probably prefer the verve and fire of a Merritt Chase to the rather staid portraits of the critic's choice. But, alas, as always, the adage art is in the eye of the beholder holds as true today as yesterday, and presumably tomorrow.
![]() |
In the Garden by William Forsyth, drawing by the artist based on painting that was exhibited in 1893 Chicago World's Fair |
In His Words, From His Brush.
In the above-cited March 13, News article, the writer describes that T. C. Steele had two paintings chosen for the World's Fair exhibit, including September, “a large canvas representing an old roadway on the side of a hill with blue hills in the distance.” The painting is further described as “somewhat dreamy in sentiment.” His other selection was On the Muscatatuck, “a morning scene looking up that picturesque stream. Trees in fall foliage are to the right, and on the left are great flat rocks forming the uneven banks of the stream.”
William Forsyth was able to state his own case about his and T. C. Steele's impressionist works that were included in the World's Fair in the same article,
“Speaking of the Muscatatuck by...Steele, ...Forsyth says: 'It represents a long stretch of terrace-like rocks of that peculiar light color found at Vernon. In the distance are trees and cornfields. A big sycamore is conspicuous in the picture. The effect is that of a warm sunny day in early autumn. The sentiment in this picture is of a fine poetic type.'
'Our pictures,' said ...Forsyth, 'are five out of the ninety chosen at Chicago...I sent in four pictures, three of which have been accepted. That is a great success and I feel quite triumphant this morning. One of the accepted pictures, and I think the best I ever painted, was made last summer. It bears the name In the Edge of the Woods. It represents a stony country such as we have about Vernon, Jennings county, this State. In the middle distance is a mass of rock in shadow with a forest behind it. Some of our Indiana trees are in front, the foliage of the beech, elm and maple figuring in the foreground with their shadows cast toward the edge of the picture. In the distance are fields.' ”
![]() |
Edge of the Woods by William Forsyth, drawing by the artist based on painting that was exhibited in 1893 Chicago World's Fair |
Forsyth continues about the 26 by 40 inch Edge of Woods canvas, and his other works,
“ 'The effect is strong sunlight and shadow; the motive, to give the shimmer of heat in contrast with the cool shadows thrown by the trees. It is a strong summer picture.
The other pictures are also subjects from Old Vernon. One represents a Hoosier garden (the painting In the Garden, image top of page). There are a couple of girl figures in it, but the motive is chiefly to show mingled...patches of color. A farm house is seen in the background. The picture is owned by Carl Lieber...and was painted in the summer of 1891. The third picture, Morning on the Muscatatuck is an autumn scene, and I think one of the best landscapes I ever made. It is owned by Louis Weissenberger...and is in the impressionist style. It has the blue and purple effects of the morning sunlight.' ”
Another long and informative feature article about Forsyth's and Steele's inclusion in the World's Fair appeared in the March 30, 1893, Indianapolis News. The article contained pictures of the five chosen artworks of the two artists, drawn by them from memory so that the local reading public could have an idea of the works in question.
The unnamed writer concluded the article by summarizing the impressionist approach to art practiced by both Forsyth and Steele at the time. It was a style new to Europe, France specifically, just a generation before, and brand-new to America in those days.
“Mr. Forsyth is one of the representatives in our State of the modern idea in art., and will help keep it well to the front in the ranks of progress...He belongs to the impressionist school, which means that he paints what he sees as he sees it, regardless of the conventions of the past...His landscapes are, for the most part, painted and finished in the open air. The effect of such work has been to get closer to nature, to get more air, and a closer realization of true values into painting...No one pretends that this school of painting has reached the acme of its success. While its beginning was surrounded with ridicule, it has now made a place for itself, and this school has now a recognized position in the advance of modern art.”
It can be observed, over the vast course of art history, at least since the Renaissance, most of the significant developments in the progress of art are blazed by individual artists on a crooked path from discovery through ridicule and perhaps, finally, renown.
For William Forsyth, a steadfast and dogged perseverance paid dividends for himself and for our State in 1893. His prophetic beginnings as a mischievous boy scrawling on the fireplace in a tiny town east of Cincinnati, through twists and turns in Indianapolis, New York City, Munich, Fort Wayne and Muncie, placed him, somehow, outside, in the open air, at an easel painting summer visions and autumn dreams. In the sun and in the shadows of a winding river backwater of southern Indiana, and ending in a Palace of Fine Art for all the world to see in Chicago.
Mark Diekhoff, October 2026
The material used in this article is being used under the fair use provisions of copyright law. The content is being used for educational purposes only, and all rights to the original content are held by their respective copyright owners. We do not claim ownership of any copyrighted material used in this work.






























