Gone and Still There.
The most obvious reminder of the location of William Forsyth's house and studio location in Irvington is a modest bronze historical marker at the north and west corner of Washington Street at Emerson Avenue. The simple marker was placed there in the mid-1980s, in a tiny park, and can be easily missed.
Forsyth's house was sold in the mid-1960s, after the death of his eldest daughter, Dorothy, who had been living there, off and on, since his death at the home in 1935.
Crossways from the historical marker, on the south and east corner at the site of the former home, is a Speedway gas and convenience store.
In the spring of 1906, Forsyth moved to Irvington with his wife Alice and two young daughters, Dorothy and Constance. Alice was heavily pregnant with the couple's third daughter, Evelyn, who would be born shortly, the following May. His career had settled down to regular teaching with a position at the fairly newly established John Herron School of Art.
The house they chose became available after the death of the previous owner, Henry Clay Parker, who was born in Irvington, before it was Irvington, to a tavern-keeping father, who lived and ran his establishment along the National Road in the pioneer days of Indiana just a generation past Statehood.
(Please see The Old National Road Inn by Steven R. Barnett here).
Parker's obituary ran in the February 20, 1904 edition of The Indianapolis Journal,
“Henry Clay Parker, one of the oldest and best-known residents of Irvington, died at his home , 15 Emerson avenue, yesterday afternoon, of Bright's disease...
He was born in Irvington, March 4, 1845, and with the exception of three and one-half years, spent in Kentucky, he had passed all of his life in Irvington.
The funeral will be held from the home...”
The house would hold that dual historical significance. First as the home of one of the area's first residents, the keeper of an inn and tavern on a lonely stretch of stagecoach trail east of Indianapolis. And next as the creative hub, the hearth and home, of William Forsyth. Both men would die in the house.
But before Irvington, William Forsyth and his wife and children had been living with his mother, brother and two sisters at a Fletcher Avenue Italianate house purchased by Forsyth's late father, Elijah John Forsyth, a number of years earlier.
It was a pivotal period of William's mid-life approaching the turn of the century that he lived in the Fletcher Avenue house. And unlike the Irvington house lost to demolition, this prior house is a survivor. Indeed, a restless and opportunistic survivor.
Turn of Century, Turns of Fate.
After his return to Indianapolis, after study abroad in Munich, Germany, and after forays teaching at upstart art schools in Ft. Wayne and Muncie, Forsyth continued his steady stream of summer holidays creating art that he would exhibit the rest of the year in shows around the city, state and country.
In the years just before 1900, he would fall in love with a former student, eighteen years his junior, Alice Atkinson. They would get married in 1897 during the summer painting holiday Forsyth took at Cedar Farm, a large mansion and estate in southern Indiana across from Rock Haven, Kentucky on the Ohio River.
(Please see Rachel Berenson Perry's exceptional book, William J. Forsyth – The Life and Work of an Indiana Artist for an exhaustive biographical study.)
And it was during the following few years, the couple lived with Forsyth's mother and his siblings in the family home on Fletcher Avenue on the near south side of Indianapolis in increasingly cramped conditions.
Forsyth would again spend summer trips at Cedar Farm and later Martinsville near the White River valley, seeking sights and inspiration.
He would also maintain a studio in the Union Trust Building in downtown Indianapolis, as presumably, there was not room at the Fletcher Avenue home.
The post-1900 period, of William Forsyth's pre-Irvington life would culminate with his exhibit of several works at his second world's fair, the Louisiana Purchase Exposition (aka the Universal Exposition of 1904), and with his acceptance of what would turn out to be a long-term, permanent teaching position at the fairly new John Herron School of Art.
An Evasive Move.
On November 13, 1982, The Indianapolis News ran a human interest column under the headline Not Your Usual Mobile Home. It provided coverage of the fate of an old house in the Fletcher Place neighborhood of Indianapolis, that serves as an apt conclusion to this series of posts about William Forsyth, before Irvington,
“In a few weeks, the (Italianate structure that once was the home of noted local artist William J. Forsyth)...will be moved from ...Fletcher Ave. to a new location (on) Lexington Ave...
Angelo Franceschina, direct of the Fountain Square Design Center...said Calvary Tabernacle...is doubling the size of its facility and needs the space on which the home sits for parking. The church owns the multi-family dwelling.
Instead of demolishing the structure...(preservation) officials suggested moving it (to a nearby location in)...Fletcher Place.
Built about 1875 and altered about 1890 to its present appearance, the house once was a center of creativity when the Elijah J. Forsyth family lived there...
William Forsyth lived in the home until 1905. His sisters, Alice and Elizabeth, both school teachers, lived there until their deaths in 1948...
Movers will raise the home – 24 feet wide, 44 feet long and 36 feet high – from the foundation on I-beams inserted under the structure and place it on dollies.
Then the home will be moved west on Fletcher..., south on Park...and east on Lexington...to its new location.”
![]() |
The Forsyth House on Lexington Avenue |
Alas, the Irvington home was not moved.
And so, today, behind and aside the 24 hour-a-day bustle and glow a Speedway gas in Irvington, is the relative quiet seclusion of a bit of land, more-or-less the same since Forsyth's time.
Inside a metal fence, beneath some towering trees, is the old Parker pioneer graveyard. The graveyard is the only part of the old Parker/Forsyth homeplace that has survived.
William Forsyth may have painted what are now the tallest of the trees in the graveyard in their younger days. He painted so many, many views of his house and garden. But aside the living trees, what other echoes linger of Forsyth's once powerful presence?
Maybe recent paving projects have turned the soil, and left a scattering of rusted relics from the long lost Forsyth place. A squeezed out oil paint tube, a paint brush ferrule, a brass gas lamp line.
Oh how to avoid the wrecker's ball?
Forsyth's last home, before Irvington, found a way.
And of course his paintings are the ultimate survivors.
A beautiful painting he did of his Irvington home, The Artist's Studio, in his signature shades of Indiana autumn, in a harmony of art nouveau hues, was just sold a few days ago at auction.
Mark Diekhoff, November 2026
The material used in this article is being used under the fair use provisions of copyright law. The content is being used for educational purposes only, and all rights to the original content are held by their respective copyright owners. We do not claim ownership of any copyrighted material used in this work.


.jpg)








