Saturday, November 7, 2026

William Forsyth, Before Irvington – Part Three


A Portrait, drawing after watercolor by William Forsyth
The Indianapolis News, Jan 6, 1894


The Group Before the Hoosier Group.

Beginning in about 1891, Munich-trained, Indianapolis painters T. C. Steele and William Forsyth began painting together summers in southern Indiana, namely the town of Vernon, as was covered in the prior post.  

Their acquaintance began at least ten years earlier in Indianapolis, in the latter years of the 1870s, when the city's first art school was established, when local exhibits were being organized by the city's founding arts organizations, and when an early informal art club was formed among some of the earliest practicing artists in the downtown area – the Bohe Club (short for Bohemian). 

Steele and Forsyth would forge a special relationship, via intercontinental correspondence, when Steele was studying in Europe and Forsyth was living in his father's house on Fletcher Street in Indianapolis.  

Steele urged Forsyth to follow him to the Royal Academy of Fine Arts in Munich, Germany, in his many letters, enticing Forsyth with the vivid detail of life and study in Europe. (See The Passage by Martin Krause, the pivotal reference for Hoosier Group study). 

Following a few years of mulling, dreaming and arranging the requisite financial patronage, Forsyth was able to begin that Munich training, just as T. C Steele was finishing.  

By the time both men had returned to Indianapolis by the last years of the 1880s, their professional and artists ties were reestablished. They began to take artist holidays together and exhibit works side by side, activities that culminated in their exhibition as the two Indianapolis artists represented in the 1893 Chicago's World's Fair. (See Part Two of this series).

In the year or so following this triumph for both men, their artist circle of two like minds would expand from a duo to a group that would eventually coalescence into what was eventually called the Hoosier Group – which endures as the most well known and respected school of painting in Indiana art history.

1894 would be a year that saw Forsyth's earlier partnership with Steele add members, first three and then four and finally five. A year when this group was first noticed as greater than the sum of the parts, not by Indiana eyes, but by several art critics in Chicago. 

There was a group before the Hoosier Group. It was made up of the same five men. 

As we shall see, they shared not so much a name, but a time, and a place. 

A place that was, in their time, at the Western frontier of the expanding nation. A nation that was, at that moment, a fading wild and rural Arcadia, soon to be devoured by teeming populations, industrialized cities and a mechanization of life beyond 19th Century imagination.   


Solo Impressions on the Ohio River.

From his beginnings to the end of his career and his life, William Forsyth was never an isolated man.  He did not have the temperament of a lone wolf artist working off to himself in an attic or far off wilderness. His early years, even before his Irvington middle-age was filled with family life, working day labor with his father and brother, then surrounded by people during his teaching and professional career. 

From about age 20 after, it was an active and social life of inter-related efforts in all things art in Indiana, from creation, to teaching, to founding, to lecturing.  

The breadth of his active involvement in the Indiana art world can be seen in examining the year 1894. From the first week of January until the last day of December that year, Forsyth's continuous activity can be followed in the local newspaper coverage. 

He began the year, again partnered with T. C. Steele, in exhibitions of their work, and by the year's end, he was among the group of five Indiana artists who would have a sensational show in Chicago catching fire with the public, fellow artists and critics alike. By year's end he would be acknowledged as part of a powerful new school of American painting.

And yet the beginning of 1894 would begin with coverage of his solo painting excursion to the Ohio River, in southernmost Indiana, the river of his youngest boyhood, in California, Ohio, east of Cincinnati.

The exhibition of his just passed summer's work was announced in an article by an unnamed writer in The Indianapolis News on January 4, 1894,

“An exhibition of the paintings of William Forsyth at his studio, at Illinois and Market streets, began to-day.”   

The article describes Forsyth's current style,

“Mr. Forsyth is, above all, an impressionist, and his later works shows no traces of the old school. In all of the latest work, the drawing has been subordinated to color effect, and an effort is made to transfer nature to the canvas exactly as she impresses the eye of the spectator.”

About the exhibition itself, the article reads,

“The main purpose is to show the summer work of the artist at and around Logan's Point, Hanover (Indiana)...Mr. Forsyth discovered the beauties of The Plow Handle, one of the most picturesque curves of the Ohio river, and the whole summer was spent in an endeavor to transfer his impressions of the beauties of the neighborhood to canvas.”

The article describes other works including a sketch in watercolors made the prior summer of one of Forsyth's pupils that summer in Vernon, Indiana (image top of page).

And another watercolor, A Silver Morning, which captured the brightness and distant effects of the river from the high ground of Logan's Point, was one highlight from the show. Also described, a single figure oil painting among the show of nearly all landscapes, At the Spring, 

“...the figure of a rustic with his back turned toward the spectator, drawing water from the spring. The rocks around the spring are damp and the bright green moss  is on their edges.”

The writer describes a favorite piece from the show,

“The best picture in oil, of the summer's work at Hanover, is called A Summer Afternoon. It is a view over a hillside, looking up the Ohio river toward Madison. At the summit of the hill there stands a cluster of lofty trees, their foliage burning green in the summer sun. A stone wall runs along the side of the hill and the sunburnt grass is overcast by a purple shadow. The river is in the distance and there is a glimpse of the blue hills beyond.”



drawing after painting by William Forsyth
of Ohio River near Hanover, Indiana
The Indianapolis News, Jan 6, 1894


The same show was covered by The Indianapolis Journal in the edition of one day later, which describes Forsyth's Indianapolis studio and specifics regarding his time in Hanover the summer just passed,

“(William Forsyth's) studio is in the building at the southeast corner of Illinois and Market streets, and after a climb of a few stairs the visitor will find himself in a tastefully and conveniently situated suite of rooms.”

The unnamed writer describes the locale of the summer's work,

“...Mr. Forsyth spent weeks at an old farm house, which was at one time occupied by a brother of President William Henry Harrison, and which was built by Captain Logan in 1818.

 

The pictures which adorn the walls of the studio were all painted within one hundred yards of this old house, which commands a view of the river from one side, and of hill, meadow and dale on the other.”   

Forsyth's technique was a novelty in Indiana at the time. The new painting style of himself and a few other European-trained local Indiana painters was a visual sensation. 

The artists were also discovering new American subjects; landscapes and motifs that were local and honest. 

A newspaper writer would provide a long and detailed feature article explaining the new painting approach of impressionism to readers unaccustomed and perhaps unprepared to view art other than the mainly realistic approaches to landscape, portrait and figure painting seen in the nation since its founding.

On January 6, 1894, in The Indianapolis News, in an article titled Impressionism In Art – What It Is and What Is Is From – Mr. Forsyth's Work by an unnamed writer explained to its readers,

“Impressionism, of which so much is now heard in art and which so many people think is some wild new vagary of artists, is nothing more nor less that one of those periodic changes which take place in technical practice and ways of looking at things among artists them-selves.”

The writer explains the necessity of such periodic and progressive change in the history of the world's evolving arts,

“Such changes seem absolutely necessary at certain intervals, serving to keep the art atmosphere moving and fresh, which otherwise might grow stale and insipid. The force of tradition and the example of a few great men if followed to closely is all to apt to lead to convention, servility, and consequent decay and ultimate death.”

The article further explains a normal progression upon the discovery of a new way of seeing by artists deemed vital and significant to history, 

“While the great inimitable laws of form and color remain the same from age to age, and form the basis of all art – the individual practice is constantly changing. When an individual greatly distinguishes himself, followers immediately spring up to carry his ideas on – sometimes farther than the originator himself. A school is founded, lives the usual course, and in time is displaced by something else.” 

The ghost writer of 1894 proved prophetic in seeing something in Forsyth's work as early as that time –  as possessing the characteristics of a great artist, one worthy of founding a new school of painting in America. A local impressionism, unique to him and a few other select seers of the local color and light of an actual rural idyll on the verge of an encroaching modern day.



drawing after painting by William Forsyth, c. 1893
The Indianapolis News, Jan 6, 1894


The expansive article follows with an outline of the 19th Century history of artistic movements subsumed by successive schools, in the European and Western cultures, such as the neo-classicists by the romantics, then the romantics by the realists, and finally the realists by the impressionists. Also noted is the late-realist artist type, described as a pleinairist, an out-door artist, leaving the confines of the studio for the open air of the natural landscape with its local color and light effects right before the eyes at the time of artistic creation.

The writer ends with a general summary of impressionism and notice that William Forsyth is a practitioner and has a current exhibit of such work on display,

“To sum up the object of the impressionists in a few words...it is seeking to render the vibration on light and color. Light and color it has certainly succeeded in bringing back to art...it has been a great gain to those who love nature and see it with a healthy, natural eye, and not through the dark spectacles of worn-out tradition. 

William Forsyth, of this city, is a student of this school of art. His studio...is now open to visitors. His summer's work is on exhibition and is attracting much attention.”  

 

Momentum and Reputation, if Not Sales.

Just a couple months later, on the society page of The Indianapolis Journal, March 18, 1894, Indianapolis artist, Miss Emma King, provides a dispatch of art news from New York,

“Miss Emma King...who is studying art in New York, writes home that the pictures which Mr. William Forsyth...sent to the (NYC) exhibitions have been received with market favor by the critics, and that Mr. Forsyth in New York is considered one of the leading water colorists in the country.”

On May 20, 1894, The Indianapolis Journal reported a group art show sponsored by the Indianapolis Art Association at the (Indianapolis) Propylaeum that included works William Forsyth, R. B. Gruelle and T. C. Steele.  

Gruelle had a watercolor titled An Old Orchard that was a scene of a subject near Irvington. The picture was purchased at the time by the Indiana Union of Literary Clubs and was given to the Propylaeum. 

Steele exhibited his ambitious and beautiful work, The Bloom on the Grape, among others at the show.

The Forsyth pieces included two oil paintings; a portrait and Summer Afternoon – Ohio River.  He also showed five watercolors; The Cabin Door, A Hill Forest, A Yellow Harmony, From a Hilltop and In the Studio. 

On November 1, The Indianapolis News reported that an exhibition of work by the late John Love who had co-founded the city's first art school was being organized by the (Indianapolis) Portfolio Club under the co-direction of William Forsyth and F. A. Heatherington. 

The Indianapolis Journal, on November 11, provided notice of perhaps the first exhibit of four of the eventual five Hoosier Group artists in a show sponsored by the (Indianapolis) Art Association at the Denison Hotel in Indianapolis. Summer work by artists T. C. Steele, R. B. Gruelle, William Forsyth and Otto Stark was shown.


The Indianapolis News, December 6, 1894


The exhibit was reviewed by both The Journal and The Indianapolis News on the same day, November 14, 1894.

Of Forsyth's works in the show, The Indianapolis News writes,

“The work of William Forsyth was late in arriving, and did not get as good a position on the walls as it deserved. This artist has been ill during the summer, and has been unable to get away from town.” 

The article advised that he was able to create watercolors in the city and nearby locations such as Garfield Park and Pleasant Run. 

The Indianapolis Journal described additional pictures by Forsyth that were in the show, including two large sketches in oil – one of a decorative multi-figure landscape and one sketchily unfinished portrait of a lady.  A colorful figure in an orchard scene and other other impressionist paintings completed his contributions.

A unique exhibit of artwork was presented as part of cultural extravaganza in Indianapolis in late November called the Flower Mission Fair held at Tomlinson Hall, with a theme based on the White City architectural design of the Chicago World's Fair of 1893. 



The Indianapolis News, December 6, 1894


Decorative arts, cuisine and refreshments, fashion and art were all combined in a midway of stimulating attractions. 

Gold and white, lace and feathers, Turkish coffee and chrysanthemums provided the decorative abundance for the mini world's fair that included booths and rooms, as opposed to pavilions, representing various countries such as Belgium and Switzerland, and industries, such as agriculture, with a cornucopia of preserved foods, baskets and wooden ware.      

The Hall's library was the portal to the fine art display of works by artists including William Forsyth, T. C. Steele and R. B. Gruelle, among many others. 

Mere weeks later,  on December 6, William Forsyth's current art career is discussed in The Indianapolis News in an expansive article covering the art and culture of the city. About Forsyth, the article reads,

“Mr. Forsyth is a thorough impressionist, and until within the last two years his work has been more appreciated in the galleries of New York and Boston than by the people of his own city...He works in both oil and water color. The same vigorous drawing and truthfulness of color is found in each. He works entirely from nature, never trusting to his memory for either form or color.”

In a December 20, 1894,  Letter to the Editor of The Indianapolis News, T. C. Steele responds to a characterization of work in a current exhibit in the city by the Dutch realist painter Anton Mauve. 

In a spirited rebuttal, Steele defended the master of what is now regarded as the Hauge School style, a style that emphasized both observation and working out-of-doors. Steele seems to celebrate and emphasize the primal attributes of his own, and soon to be Hoosier Group style, when he writes,

“I wish to say a word about the Mauve exhibit. An impression has gotten abroad that this exhibition is of sketches and studies, and consequently, while interesting to artists and students, is not attractive to the general public. It is true, the pictures are in the main sketches and studies, but none the less interesting, even to the general public on that account.

Such a master of expression was this great Dutchman that these sketches and studies mean more, and are nearly finished productions, in any true sense, than the finished pictures of most other artists. They are the beautiful productions of a rarely gifted man, who was by universal consent one of the greatest modern Dutch painters. He was most sensitive to the poetry of his own land, to its gray skies and low horizons, to its lush meadows, herds of feeding cattle, and its quiet canals. His technic is so transparent and successful that even in his slightest sketch we get very close to his thought.

It is by the rarest good fortune that the art association is able to show this collection...and...a great misfortune that the public should fail to see...its great artistic value. Let every lover of art make it a point to see this collection before it leaves the city.”  

The characterization of several of Forsyth's works from that summer as sketches takes on new meaning when considering the thoughtful words of T. C. Steele. 

Steele, and a few other impressionist fellows of the developing Indiana style would prioritize a reverent honesty in the depiction of the local landscape as well as a spontaneous, and perhaps rapid, execution of the sensations of color, light and subject. They would insist on meeting nature on her own terms, face-to-face, in painting encounters out-of-doors.

The following day in the same paper, an unnamed editor or writer responds to T. C. Steele's letter with a keen observation about these proto-Hoosier Groupers, and the state of public apathy about their talented work at the time,

“Indianapolis is fortunate indeed in having these (Mauve) pictures here...We shall make little use of the  golden opportunity, indeed, if we do not see them.

...we might add that no long time ago there closed in the same room (at the Denison Hotel) an exhibit of paintings by painters certainly not so celebrated as Mauve, of greater merit than can be easily set out here. The painters were T. C Steele, William Forsyth, Otto Stark and R. B Gruelle. There were some hundred canvases, covering a wide range of subjects. There was not a canvas among them that was not interesting from a popular point of view. Some of them were 'sunbursts' of color, all of them graphically portraying things which the eye is well acquainted with as to make a general appeal. 

These pictures were for sale, ranging as low in price as $20 and as high as $250 (approx $780 to $9,800 today adjusted for inflation). They were exhibited at a time when people were buying gifts; when there was spent tens and hundreds of dollars for furniture, bric-a-brac, jewelry, drapery...and things generally which delight those who live in Philistia. But not a single one of these canvases found a purchaser. Indeed they found few to come and look at them.”

If not sales, for these men, in Indianapolis, a certain notice and notoriety would coalesce yet before the end of the year.  And it would occur once again out-of-town, in the magic land of Chicago – America's second largest metropolis at the time – the location of the prior year's success of T. C Steele and William Forsyth.


Five Stars Are Born.

Stars are born of clouds of gas and dust. A new art is a new being. It is formed upon news legs, awkward and teetering, like those of a child who has just learned to walk. With joy, each new step a discovery and a destination not yet experienced before. When a prior art becomes dusty and inflated, is when it gives birth to new lights in the sky.

Just as 1894 was ending, The Indianapolis News announced the birth of five such stars with a front-page, above-the-fold column about a current exhibit in Chicago under the headline – The Indianapolis Group and the sub-headline An Exhibit That Is Creating Interest In The Chicago Art World.

The article heralds the start of something new,

“Chicago art critics now admit that Indiana is not so far behind in the line of fine arts  as they had supposed. They are at deeply interested in the paintings of T. C. Steele, William Forsyth, R. B. Gruelle, Otto Stark and J. O. Adams, on exhibition at sculptor Lorado Taft's studio, in the Chicago Athenaeum Building.

The artists of Chicago, with scarcely an exception, have visited the exhibition and are unanimous in praising the work shown.” 

The sculptor, Taft, became acquainted with T. C. Steele a couple of years prior, when he was on the selection committee that chose artists for the World's Fair, and explains the genesis for the current exhibit in his studio,

“I heard the painters (on the selection committee) discussing the 'new man' whom they had discovered, and they spoke so highly of the unknown artist of Indianapolis that I was anxious to know his work. 

The...examples in the Art Palace (building at the World's Fair) by Mr. Steele were certainly worthy of enthusiasm, and I took pleasure in pointing them out to my students.” 

Taft explained that Hamlin Garland, president of the (Chicago) Central Art Association,

“...(recently) received a letter from Mr. Steele, expressing his sympathy with the work of the association, and adding as an item of interest that he, with four companions, had just given a little exhibition, at home, of their recent works.” 

Steele's notice and information about the group of Indiana painters, of which he was one, led to the Chicago Association of arranging the current show in Taft's studio to allow Chicago the opportunity to view the new 'Western art.'

The press release by the Association which accompanied the show opening would prove prescient,

“To the Art Lovers of Chicago:

The Central Art Association takes peculiar pleasure  in presenting...the work of five 'Hoosier' painters, for, aside from their inherent excellence as artists, the history of their development has special significance. It exemplifies all the difficulties in the way of original Western art and foreshadows its ultimate victory.

These men were isolated from their fellow-artists; they were surrounded by apparently the most unpromising material, yet they set themselves to their thankless task right manfully, and this exhibition demonstrates the power  of the artist's eye to find floods of color, graceful forms and interesting compositions everywhere.

These artists have helped the people of Indiana to see the beauty in their own quiet landscape. They have not only found interesting things to paint in things near at hand; they have made these chosen scenes interesting to others. Therein lies their significance.” 

The article goes on to quote Philadelphia art critic Robert Vonnah about the work in the exhibit,

“The work of each (of the five artists) is very frank and honest, is charming in colors, and is characterized by great breadth and simplicity in the handling.

...These men give promise to equal any of our American artists, and I am glad to see it.” 

On the last day of the year, The Indianapolis News would run another additional coverage of the Chicago 'Indianapolis Group' exhibit by reprinting two Chicago newspaper art reviews.  

The first, a long review in the Chicago Inter Ocean by an unnamed writer, describes the Indiana brand of impressionism on display, and a specific work by the show's most exuberant impressionist, William Forsyth,

“The...exhibition...which opened...in Lorado Taft's studio...is made up entirely of the work of Indiana artists. It is by no means a large one, yet it is interesting. More than that, it is charming. It is not impressionist enough to drive (a) conventional person wild, nor is it sufficiently conventional to cause and impressionist to brand it tame. Really in the pictures there is a happy medium. Remembering them there is only one, William Forsyth's Reflections, which could by any manner of means  be described as 'rampant' and bristling with challenges to the old school artist, who paints what he sees in an orderly and methodical manner, calculated to impress one with the idea that all nature is laid out on a straight line.

Reflections is what the person unlearned in art technique is apt to call rather roughly painted, but what the critic describes as 'broad in treatment,' broad meaning that the paint is laid on in daubs, which makes it unpleasant to approach too near. But how beautiful the effect is when half way across the room!”  

The critic continues about Reflections, the most rampant of Forsyth's pictures, and all the pictures in the show,

“At...distance, the colors blend and sunshine streams out of the canvas. 

...It looks, to be sure, very pretty, and the great gnarled trees upon the bank come bravely to the front, but it is...after a few moments' study that one perceives a pool of water in the background, and in it reflected shadows from above – not darkened images of autumn hues, but the golden and crimson glory of the dying year. And because of the artist's daring, to so mirror the beauty of the autumn leaves, one feels that one may almost dare to call it the picture of the exhibition.”   

The other reprinted review from the Chicago Herald, also by an unnamed critic, is second to christen the five artists as the 'Indianapolis Group.' 

“A small collection of pictures is now on exhibition in Lorado Taft's studio...The men represented are those known as the 'Indianapolis Group'...

The collection is not only suggestive, but convinces one that these vigorous and studious men of Indiana have created a school of landscape painting that the West has every reason to praise and respect. There is in it at least the spirit of American national art. 

...They are content to delineate the beauty they find in their own quiet landscapes. In this collection there is not one dyke of Holland, nor a pair of wooden shoes; even the downs of Brittany are absent – in fact, it is free from all foreign notes; its accent is American.”

In the early 1890s, William Forsyth began painting in a partnership with T. C. Steele. Over the course of his eventful 1894, he continued his studies alone and then he began, for him, yet another school of art. Not of brick and motor this time, but flesh and blood, and mind.  He exhibited as a group of three drawn to nature and the open air, and then four, and finally, of five. 

By December 31 the school of art had been discovered, and first recognized as an American force to be reckoned with. And he had been noticed as perhaps its wildest eye.

Mark Diekhoff, November 2026


The material used in this article is being used under the fair use provisions of copyright law. The content is being used for educational purposes only, and all rights to the original content are held by their respective copyright owners. We do not claim ownership of any copyrighted material used in this work.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Jay Parnell's 'Dust' at Harrison Center

Temporal (detail) by Jay Parnell The Deep Baroque of Jay Parnell In his recent painting exhibition Dust at Harrison Center, longtime Indian...